Welcome to M1911.ORG
The M1911 Pistols Organization Forums Site


Dear members,
Please make sure the email address we have for you, is correct and valid.


Sponsors Panel
If you intend to buy something from the companies advertising above, or near the bottom of our pages, please use their banners in our sites. Whatever you buy from them, using those banners, gives us a small commission, which helps us keep these sites alive. You still pay the normal price, our commission comes from their profit, so you have nothing to lose, while we have something to gain. Your help is appreciated.
If you want to become a sponsor and see your banner in the above panel, click here to contact us.

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 16

Thread: Norinco Metal Question

THREAD CLOSED
This is an old thread. You can't post a reply in it. It is left here for historical reasons.Why don't you create a new thread instead?
  1. #1
    Join Date
    4th November 2004
    Posts
    42
    Posts liked by others
    0

    Norinco Metal Question

    I wish I had a decent scale so I could weigh my new "Rinco, but it seems heavier than my Colt Govt Model compared side by side.

    I have heard that Norincos use very good steel.

    Is it REALLY heavier? Anybody know?

    Thanks

  2. #2
    Join Date
    24th December 2005
    Location
    manila
    Posts
    103
    Posts liked by others
    0
    i got this from another 1911 site, http://forums.1911forum.com/showthread.php?t=145099


    There is nothing wrong with Norinco 1911's you can be sure of that. Here is a copy of a post from a friend of mine who is an engineer in Ottawa that will give you some idea of the quality of the steel in Norincos.

    "Allright, well let me first start by explaining a few things about steel in general, including Ordnance grades of steel. Hardness does not necessarily equate to brittleness, that is a function of heat treating and alloy. Even softer steels can crack and be brittle, it's a matter of how the internal stresses are relieved, or not, by annealing and hardening processes, as well as upon carbon on other constituent elements found in the steel.

    Also should mention, I'm comparing apples to apples, so only the CroMo Colt is being compared to the CroMo Norinco here. The stainless guns have their own quirks (like spalling problems, corrosion resistance benefits, etc.)

    In layman's terms, the more important characteristics to crafting firearms is the toughness of the steel and modulous of elasticity of the steel. You want steel that is ductile enough to flex at the microscopic level and return to its original shape but hard enough to have good wear resistance and, in higher end guns, be able to take and keep the desired finish without dinging up too easily.

    Now if we want to talk about relative hardness of steels, Norincos are made from a different steel formulation than Colts are. Comparing Rockwell hardnesses really won't tell you much, but as a general observation, on average the Norincos are at least 30% harder on the surface than most other 1911's, including the Colt. This does not mean they are more brittle - it means that the alloy used to Make the Norincos (5100 tool steel*) results in a much harder surface when heat treated than does the Colt alloy (4140 Ordnance grade tool steel*).

    *Although the exact alloy formulations are "industrial secrets", destructive testing done in the USA by the DCM (circa 1997) determined that Colt uses 4140 and the Chinese formulation used in 1911's and M14S receivers is an exact match to AISI 5100 series steel.

    Perhaps this is the time to mention something else about Colts. Colt does not use the same alloy today it used in WW2 and earlier. In WW1, the guns were not even given what we think of today as "heat treating". Those older guns were only spot-treated at high stress areas and today have a rather high incidence of slide cracking using full factory loads due to a number of factors, including metal fatigue, crack propagation, creep, etc. coupled with the fact that vast portions of the slide and frame have no treatment at all. That being said, the steel is very ductile and in the event of failure, it should just bend and crack - not fracture like a grenade. A good thing, but at the same time - these babies should be collected and admired more than turned into a range marathon pistol!

    I could get further into heat treating, including annealing, case hardening, gas carburizing, cyanide dips, etc. and the resulting pearlitic and/or martensitic grain structures, but frankly, unless you work in a foundry or have a mechanical engineering degree and understanding of materials science, it would be way too far over everyone's head so I'll try to keep this explanation understandable for the average fellow

    Now for a short note on Chinese steel "quality". The Chinese are as advanced as we are in Steel production. Is Chicom steel of poorer quality on average on a gross domestic production basis? Yes, absolutely. This is because the majority of China's manufacturing is devoted to the Wal-Marts of the world at a very low price point, so cheaper steels are generally produced and used for those products. The steel used in their weapons, however, is every bit as up to snuff as North American steel is.

    So now we get into the 5100 alloy Norinco 1911 in particular. 5100 is an EXCELLENT receiver material. It hardens very well on the surface but maintains an adequately ductile core. This gives great wear resistance and great resistance to plastic deformation (deformation that causes the parts to permanently deform or warp). The one achilles heel to 5100 series alloys is that they are notoriously hard to machine. Norinco, I suspect, machines their parts with carbide cutters prior to heat treating. On a finished gun the only way you're going to cut it with HSS mill bits is if you spot-anneal the steel with a torch first. Most smiths have to buy carbide mill bits to work the steel, and even then there's a very high tool wear rate. This is probably why so few smiths will do Novak cuts to a Norinco slide - they probably only have HSS tooling!

    5100 alloy is, most probably, the alloy most manufacturers WOULD chose to build receivers if tool bits were cheap and labor costs were low. It really does have better end-product properties than 4140 steel does, and it's also easier to smelt at the steel mill and forges beautifully. Virtually all Cro-Mo guns made in the west that aren't cast, however, are made of 4140 or other 4100 series alloys. 4140 is an entirely adequate steel for use in guns, it also wears tools at a much slower rate and can still be machined easily after hardening. The Chinese are fortunate in that they make many of the tool steel bits on the market (cheap supply) and lobor costs are very low. This makes 5100 steel actually cheaper for them to use b/c of the lower costs associated with making the steel stock.

    All this to say, you can complain about the design, fit, finish, and economics of a Norinco 1911. But frankly, trashing the steel is a bigotted and unfounded arguement based on ignorance and reliance on the Go-USA writings of most internet experts "

    I hope this gives you a better perspective of the Norinco 1911.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    29th May 2004
    Location
    Athens, Greece, Earth
    Posts
    28,050
    Posts liked by others
    178
    Blog Entries
    2
    Some years ago, when Wilson Combat was more of a custom house and less of a manufacturer, he accepted four brands of pistols for making custom work on them. Colt, Norinco, Springfield and Para Ordnance.

    That should mean something!
    John Caradimas SV1CEC
    The M1911 Pistols Organization
    http://www.m1911.org

  4. #4
    Join Date
    24th December 2005
    Location
    manila
    Posts
    103
    Posts liked by others
    0
    im surprise smith and wesson wasn't in their list.....

  5. #5
    Join Date
    27th April 2006
    Posts
    31
    Posts liked by others
    0
    Good info Kcboy, nice post research. It's very interesting and informative.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    29th May 2004
    Location
    Athens, Greece, Earth
    Posts
    28,050
    Posts liked by others
    178
    Blog Entries
    2
    Quote Originally Posted by KCboy
    im surprise smith and wesson wasn't in their list.....
    Smith & Wesson was NOT making 1911s back then. Another one of the top makers though, was in the market and Wilson won't touch their guns. I'll say no more.
    John Caradimas SV1CEC
    The M1911 Pistols Organization
    http://www.m1911.org

  7. #7
    Join Date
    4th November 2004
    Posts
    42
    Posts liked by others
    0
    Very informative. thanks

  8. #8
    Join Date
    24th December 2005
    Location
    manila
    Posts
    103
    Posts liked by others
    0
    atleast we have a higher respect for norincos even if they're prices are not as high as the colts.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    27th July 2005
    Location
    Vancouver
    Posts
    238
    Posts liked by others
    0
    KCBoy you're the man! That is one heck of an informative post. At last, my norincos will get the respect they deserve. My friend already told me that the Norks lack tradition of Colts. I'd say the **** with tradition. I'll create mine with the Nork. A friend told me that it is made by communists. I'd say the heck with it, as long as I can shoot a bad guy with it I wouldn't care if it came from Zimbabwe.

    Best regards to you and keep it coming KCBOy!
    Colt made the 1911 tradition. Norinco made it more popular because of the price.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    31st May 2004
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    2,111
    Posts liked by others
    1
    The post quoted was one I copied from canadiangunutz. the author is Claven2, an engineer from Ottawa. The post was made at my request after a thread got heated over there regarding the quality of Norinco steel.

    In the last statement Cloven2 makes a direct comment regarding those who knock the Norincos. This statement is directed at a number of fellows on the candadiangunutz forum who had made some rather outrageous statements regarding the product. If you are reading this quote posted please do not take the statement personally as it is not directed at anyone on this board.

    John I am sure Claven2 would not mind if you made a sticky of that quote - ex the last sentence as it answers the question regarding Norinco steel.


    Take Care

    Bob
    " Back when we audited the FBI academy in 1947, I was told that I ought not to use my pistol in their training program because it was not fair. Maybe the first thing one should demand of his sidearm is that it be unfair."
    - LtCol. Jeff Cooper as quoted in Guns & Ammo magazine, January 2002
    Likes (1) :
    Big Coulee (6th April 2017)


Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  



Sponsors Panel
If you intend to buy something from Brownells, please use their banners above. Whatever you buy from them, gives us a small commission, which helps us keep these sites alive. You still pay the normal price, our commission comes from their profit, so you have nothing to lose, while we have something to gain. Your help is appreciated.
If you want to become a sponsor and see your banner in the above panel, click here to contact us.

Non-gun-related supporters.
Thank you for visiting our supporters.