I have been watching this site for years trying to gain knowledge. And I have learned a lot. I'm interested in purchasing a Colt Defender and have read only good about them as compared to other brands. One of my concerns was the alloy frame wearing out before it's time. They look great and feel right. Any comments would be appreciated. Thanks, Jim.

To be fully informed, read about the reliability issues short 1911's have due to changes in function. It is commonly noted that they will not be as reliable as a full size 1911.

Reliability should be your primary concern for a carry pistol, more so that small size and whether they "feel right" or not.

Reliability is more important than "feeling right." "Functioning right" is a better thing to evaluate than "feel."

The defender is a great little pistol. Your concern about the alloy frame not being as durable as a steel frame is a valid one. While not a Colt I have had one frame crack on an alloy 3" 1911 after 6000 rounds and several years. I wouldn't worry about reliability. I rather doubt the manufacturer had anything to do with the the frame cracking. If you'd like to know more about that; pm me. I'd rather not mention the brand here as I don't really want to contribute to turning your thread into a brand a vs brand b thread. Now to address what has been mentioned about reliability. 1944Colt is correct. There is plenty of documentation of the sub 4.25" pistols not being as reliable. All of that documentation is on the error net though. You have to understand what you'll read is am mixture of lies and truth. Some people just make up stories to stir other people up too. I've owned several 3" pistols including a Colt New Agent (same as a defender) all have been as reliable as you could possibly want. I had a both 4.25" and 5" pistols that gave me more trouble. Having said that, I no longer own any 3" or alloy 1911's but that is for different reasons all together; it has nothing to do with reliability or alloy durability. I think you would be happy with a Defender. If is should crack (not likely) Colt will replace it as the other manufacturer did with mine. Good luck.

I own 2 three inch bbl .45 cals. One HK USPcT and the Colt Defender.

The colt is a great shooter and a great carry 1911.

I've only got about 1K rds down the tube but there have been no issues with it so far.

I had a trigger job done on it and it breaks clean at 3.5 lbs.

My experience is that 3" 1911s are finicky. The shortest I'd go is 3.5 as in Officers. I have 2 Colt Officers, I carry a 4.25 Colt Commander. My 2 cents.

I would hope you could shoot a couple before you buy. A 3.x inch any 45 ACP is not a good gun as a first gun IMHO.

__________________
NRA Life Member

The original question only applies to the durability of the frame not whether a defender is reliable or if he should get one? What makes anyone think this is the original posters first hand gun? My first 1911 style pistol was a 3" pistol. I'm just saying.

While it is generally accepted lore that short 1911s are "finicky," the Colt Defender in general seems to be about the least finicky of the lot -- perhaps because Colt has been building 1911s (including short 1911s) longer than anyone else. As for myself, while I don't own a Defender I do own a para Slim Hawg, which is also a 3" model on an alloy frame. It has been 100 percent reliable with any ammunition I feed it.

As to the durability of an alloy frame compared to steel -- no, it's not as durable. But a 3" Defender is not a range blaster, it's a carry pistol. This type of pistol is (again, in general) intended to be carried much and shot seldom. So if the life expectancy is 50,000 rounds instead of 150,000 rounds ... how long will it take you to put 50,000 rounds through it?

The important thing with an alloy frame (IMHO) is to keep the slide rails well-lubed, and not shoot a lot of +P ammo through it. Carry +P if you wish ... but practice with standard power ammo.

Better yet, use one of the new "short barrel" loads that are designed specifically for this type of application.

I would have no hesitation whatsoever about buying a Defender.

__________________
Hawkmoon
On a good day, can hit the broad side of a barn ... from the inside

and let's not forget the caveat not to use magazines with a Devel type follower.
to prevent possible scoring of the feedramp from follower tilt...

http://forum.m1911.org/showthread.php?t=15281

shown here in the bottom right hand corner as a McCormick.

__________________
cold on ice it's a Deadman's touch...

I've owned 2 Defenders and felt that they were reliable and quite accurate for a smaller gun. I'd buy another one for sure.

The alloy frame really is a long term issue, and as has been posted use only the newer magazines with the improved follower or the flat follower.

FWIW: We acquired my brothers Defender in a trade and the frame was cracked between the mag well and the cut-outs for the do-dads that operate the firing pin safety. COLT did replace this frame, N/C.

__________________
Ken
"I like Colts and will die that way"
"It seems to me that I have forgotten more than I remember"