Sig or Smith Commander

[dep2386]

I am shopping for a commander sized pistol. I have narrowed my search down to either a Sig Platinum Carry or a Smith PD. Does anybody have any feedback on either of these models. I know the Platinum model will not be released until after the Shot Show. But any feedback on any of the Sig Commander sized pistols would be greatly appreciated. The Sig seems to have a lot nice features like checkered front strap and night sights.

[Poohgyrr]

I'm interested in what others have to say about this, but between the two you ask about, I'd definitely get the Smith - it uses standard holsters and I believe is closer to the original design. And I have read a ton of good reviews, with very few bad ones, on the Smith.

I'd also look closely at a Colt.

[dep2386]

Well, I bought the Sig. I am very happy with it very accurate with an excellent trigger pull. I am still interested in getting a Smith 1911.